It’s certainly a diverse and long list of retailers: Target. Walmart. Dollar General. Best Buy. 7-Eleven. Kroger. Lululemon. L.L.Bean. Saks. Givenchy, Armani, and Bottega Ve-neta. But it turns out they all have something in common: Their top seats are—or soon will be—held by someone new to the job.
If this sounds familiar, it is: Retail is far from the first industry to experience high CEO turnover. Leader exits tend to be correlated with disruption, like that of the post-pandemic period, when healthcare-CEO turnover hit record highs. But for now, retail holds the crown. Last year, the consumer sector had the highest CEO turnover of any industry worldwide, at 17 percent, with 54 exits. Now, a year later, the old CEOs have said sayonara, and most of their successors are on the job. “It is recognition that retail is in trouble,” says retail expert Paco Underhill, author of Why We Buy. “The line be-tween cyber and physical is getting fuzzier and fuzzier, and some retail icons are going the way of the dinosaurs.”
What now? Buckle up. A sports analogy: Typically, coaches play against each other’s teams for decades, developing familiarity with each other’s respective inclinations. When a new coach comes in, rivals don’t know the new playbook, so for a couple of years, they have to guess. “Past competitive behavior becomes less predictive,” says former CEO Arie Brish, a board director and adjunct faculty member at St. Edward’s University.
Overall CEO turnover in the US has declined this year, but retail is still reeling. This is perhaps because the sector is a bellwether for major changes, including the ongoing e-commerce revolution, and, more recently, the budget-eating advent of gen AI. Mean-while, 61 percent of consumers say price matters more than it did two years ago. As consumer habits change quickly, some retailers are struggling to pinpoint who, exactly, their e-commerce customers are and what they want.
On paper, retail is actually flush, with after-tax profits at large US companies nearly doubling. But most of that revenue has come not from stores but from investment and other non-operating gains; the core business has had to absorb tariff costs and uneven demand. At the same time, boards are noticing that executives who led their organiza-tions through the pandemic don’t seem to have the skill set needed for the age of AI. They performed well in higher-growth scenarios, but now firms are running during a low-growth era that’s driven by price rather than volume.
Since the newest leaders have (mostly) arrived, much of the retail industry is in a wait-and-see posture. “When so many leaders are new and an industry has long-standing ways of doing things, the barriers go down,” says Jane Edison Stevenson, global vice chair for board and CEO services at Korn Ferry. “There can be a new level of inven-tion.” New leaders typically explore the business for ninety days before they make changes, often by swapping out leaders one level below the C-suite. In turn, numerous employees wait to see which way the wind blows. Expect big thinking. “It enables peo-ple to think more broadly,” says Stevenson.



