What Happens When Committee Chairs Stay Too Long


Long-serving committee chairs may bring valuable expertise, but do the returns diminish over time?
Key Takeaways:
- A new study found that 75% of companies had no established mechanism for refreshing committee chairs.
- Boards risk preserving veteran leadership at the expense of developing future committee chairs.
- Experts advocate boards have succession plans for committee chairs, among other measures to help prepare potential new leaders.
Seventy-five percent of companies lack succession plans for the chair.
The audit-committee chair had held the position for nearly a decade. She knew the company’s finances intimately, had strong relationships with management and the external auditors, and was widely respected by her fellow directors. There was no urgent need to replace her. But when the board considered who might eventually succeed her, they realized that no other director had the experience needed to chair the committee. By keeping an effective chair in place for so many years, had the board failed to prepare the next generation of committee leaders?
It’s a question more boards may need to think through. A 2025 survey found that 75% of companies had no established mechanism for refreshing committee chairs. And according to a 2024 survey, over two-thirds of boards rotated committee chairs only as needed, while just 27% had committee chairs formally mentor potential successors. Yet recent research suggests that the duration of committee leadership can have real consequences. One intriguing example: A 2025 study in Managerial Auditing Journal found a U-shaped relationship between the tenure of audit committee chairs and the quality of financial reporting: Outcomes initially improved as chairs gained experience, but eventually performance started to decline.
“One person being the chair of a committee for 10 years is probably not a great way to develop future chairs or other leaders.”
“One person being the chair of a committee for 10 years is probably not a great way to develop future chairs or other leaders,” says Claudia Pici Morris, senior client partner and North American CEO and board succession solutions leader at Korn Ferry. Other directors, she argues, need opportunities to assume responsibilities and learn to effectively work with their colleagues. Jane Edison Stevenson, global vice chair of board and CEO services and global leader of board and CEO succession at Korn Ferry, agrees: “It’s about getting people additional experience.”
But making room for new leaders isn’t a reason to arbitrarily rotate committee chairs. Experts point out that long-serving committee chairs accumulate institutional knowledge and relationships that can be difficult to replace, particularly in technically demanding areas such as audit oversight. Nor should boards risk disrupting committees’ work simultaneously merely to give more directors leadership experience. Instead, committee-chair transitions should be staggered and coordinated, says Stevenson: “We’re not talking about rotation—we’re really talking about refresh, because it isn’t a great idea to have all the committee chairs just play musical chairs.” A transition in one committee, she explains, should prompt consideration of its implications for the others: “If we’re going to transition the compensation-committee chair at this time, we need to think: What are the implications around the finance or the audit committee, the nom-gov committee, etc.?” That requires looking ahead, and Stevenson advocates preparing directors to take on committee-chair responsibilities well in advance of vacancies. That might mean bringing in a new director early enough to become familiar with a committee’s work or giving existing members opportunities to demonstrate their leadership capabilities.

Ultimately, the goal is to make committee leadership development an ongoing responsibility, rather than a haphazard response to a departure. All boards want to preserve expertise, but committee leadership shouldn’t become the exclusive province of a few veteran directors. As Stevenson puts it, “You can effect positive change on multiple fronts by getting people additional experience as board leaders.”
Learn more about Korn Ferry’s Board Succession capabilities.
