When Extraordinary CEO Pay Becomes Ordinary


One-time CEO pay awards are soaring. Now the practice is creating some unintended consequences.
Key Takeaways:
- S&P 500 companies granted $1.7 billion in special executive awards last year, up 50% from 2024.
- The increasing use of these extraordinary awards has created challenges for boards with investors and other stakeholders.
- Experts worry that boards are normalizing the use of these awards instead of reserving them for special situations
Are Moonshot Pay Awards Worth the Cost?
The board had a problem. The CEO was eager to retire, but the company was in the middle of a major transformation, and a successor wasn’t quite ready to take over. Directors needed another couple of years from their chief executive, but how to convince her to stay? The fix: A large one-time up-front grant of several years’ worth of equity, in exchange for retention.
One-time pay incentives are growing more common—and more substantial. S&P 500 companies granted $1.7 billion in special executive awards last year, up 50% from 2024, according to Equilar data. Nearly half of the companies made at least one such award over the past two years, while a quarter made multiple grants. Another study identified 67 “moonshot” grants—worth a total of $6.3 billion—offered to executives between 2020 and mid-2025. But the proliferation of these incentives isn’t without some intangible costs, whether it’s executives who feel slighted by industry colleagues’ larger grants or investors who question the awards’ ballooning values.
Moonshot awards come in two varieties, explains Irv Becker, vice chairman of Korn Ferry’s Executive Pay and Governance practice. The first kind, which tends to be used for retention, combines several years of equity compensation in one up-front grant—a structure that allows executives to benefit immediately from stock-price appreciation on the entire grant, rather than incrementally, on shares portioned out over time. This approach can be particularly useful when a board wants a CEO to postpone retirement or stay through a major transaction. “A year or two could be exactly what you need for the transition you’re planning,” Becker says. The second kind of incentive is a special outperformance grant, layered on top of regular compensation, that rewards executives over longer time horizons for surpassing already ambitious targets, usually focused on stock price or total shareholder return. In many cases it never pays out, given the difficulty of achieving its goals.
But the increasing use of these extraordinary awards has created some complications: For one, executives who don’t receive them may feel slighted. Jane Edison Stevenson, global vice chair of board and CEO services and global leader of board and CEO succession at Korn Ferry, says that executives can view these awards “as a statement of how they are valued by the board—and people are naturally very sensitive about their compensation.” What’s more, as the escalating grants become a trend, she says, they can become normalized: “In any sector, when prices get raised or lowered, everyone feels that peer pressure—and others start thinking, ‘You must not value me if I didn’t get a moonshot award.’”
“The retention risks that many of these awards are designed to address are sometimes more feared than real.”
Of course, shareholders and proxy advisors have legitimate reasons to question the augmenting of compensation packages. Up-front equity grants may sometimes be offered unnecessarily, says Don Lowman, a global leader in the Total Rewards practice at Korn Ferry: “The retention risks that many of these awards are designed to address are sometimes more feared than real.” Becker says that “in almost every case, proxy advisors will recommend voting against” overperformance grants—but that boards now increasingly view that opposition as a manageable cost. “If this is the right thing for the company, then you deal with the ‘against’ recommendation—it’s painful for a year,” says Becker. “It’s a lot of outreach and engagement, but you get through it.” As for whether the awards actually work: A Stanford study of 40 so-called “mega” grants (defined as having an initial value of at least $100 million) found that most paid out only a fraction of their expected value, and that the companies granting them undershot market benchmarks.

Meanwhile, each new one-time incentive award gives other boards another precedent to consider, and executives another way to compare their compensation with those of their peers. “When these things start popping up, they become part of the conversation,” Becker says. Or as Stevenson puts it, “It’s a very slippery slope, and we’re on it.”
Learn more about Korn Ferry’s Executive Compensation capabilities.
