The CEO Resigned Unexpectedly. Now What?

The CEO Resigned Unexpectedly. Now What?

Unexpected CEO exits are more common today than everbefore. But Korn Ferry research shows boards haven’t adjusted successionplanning to this new reality.

Key Takeaways:

  • A new Korn Ferry study found that one in four boards are not prepared for a CEO transition.
  • The study comes at a time when unplanned or emergency CEO exits are on the rise.
  • Experts say boards need to be ready when circumstances alter their succession plans.

When Succession Happens Suddenly

The board chair asked a simple question: If our CEO needed to be replaced tomorrow, would we be prepared for the transition?

“Boards still think they are in control of the timing of CEOsuccession when the fact is that in many cases, they are not.”

Emergency successions were once rare in the corporate world. But even if sudden exits from the corner office are far more common today, boards are surprisingly unprepared for them. Indeed, in a new Korn Ferry study, one in four boards were not prepared for a CEO transition, with serious consequences for the firms in question. “Boards still think they are in control of the timing of CEO succession when the fact is that in many cases, they are not,” says Jane Edison Stevenson, global leader of board and CEO succession at Korn Ferry.

To be sure, a recent high-profile CEO departure is making headlines, but a lot of departures—and succession plans—go under the general public’s radar. This year alone so far, 17 other CEOs have resigned due to misconduct issues, more than three times as many as in 2025. Being unprepared is obvious when there is no succession plan. But even when a plan exists, business conditions can change at a speed the plan can’t adapt to. A traditional cyclical approach to succession planning may leave companies unprepared to secure the kind of leadership the new situation demands.  

The Korn Ferry data shows that unplanned successions can cost firms financially, as well as in other ways. The study compared the stock prices of companies that named a successor within 15 days of an unplanned transition with those that delayed doing so. Over the first two quarters following the leadership change, the former outperformed the latter by 3.8 percentage points. Hastily picked successors are also judged more harshly, at least according to the data. The report shows that new CEOs elevated as part of a planned succession had an average tenure of 6.6 years, with only 27% leaving within three years. By contrast, in unplanned successions, the appointed CEO left within three years 57% of the time and averaged barely more than 3.9 years in the job.  

Tierney Remick, vice chairman and co-leader of Korn Ferry’s Global Board and CEO practice, says boards haven’t moved fast enough to adjust their succession-planning processes to the new realities of leadership. “Business changes so fast that a growth story today could become a turnaround story tomorrow,” she says. Picking a CEO hastily, she says, is something like selecting a college quarterback high in the draft and asking him to turn around a losing NFL franchise immediately. “Neither is prepped for the circumstances they are about to enter,” she says, “but they are expected to succeed right away.” Carrying the analogy further, Remick notes that it takes an entire team, not just one person, to make an organization successful. That fact, she says, shouldn’t be overlooked given the rise in the number of first-time CEOs.  

What compounds the problem is that boards facing an unplanned succession are under so much pressure that they can forget—or neglect—to think about their desired business outcomes. Essential to any successful succession plan, Stevenson says, is a board comprising directors that understand the company’s needs and the kind of leadership they call for. Put another way, one leader may be the right choice to take the firm in a new strategic direction; another executive may be better suited to improving financial performance; yet another could satisfy an activist who’s been demanding a merger or sale. “The bigger the pipeline of successors, the better the chances that the CEO who is chosen will be successful,” says Stevenson.

Board & CEO Services

Better leaders for a better world

Learn more

CEO succession, adds Remick, is increasingly about readiness,both in terms of who the board selects and how it prepares the next leader. Andon that point, boards aren’t doing enough. Though 60% of boards believesuccession planning should be a continuous process, only 17% review plansquarterly. “Some boards may not want to drive succession planning because theydon’t want the CEO to leave,” says Remick, “and those boards won’t be able tomake effective decisions for the business when circumstances change.” Or, as ClaudiaPici Morris, a Korn Ferry senior client partner and leader of its CEO and BoardSuccession Solutions, points out, "Internal succession planning process isstill a muscle that hasn't been built across the organization."

Learn more about Korn Ferry’s Board and CEO Services capabilities.

Featured Topics
Leadership
Board & CEO Services
Board
CEO
Board & CEO Services